I’ll admit it: right up until 2:30 pm Italian time on Saturday 14 November, I was convinced that the Eurovision Song Contest Asia would stay forever locked in the drawer of the fandom’s many forbidden dreams. Back in 2007, when I first fell for Eurovision, moving the format to Asia was already being billed as imminent – only to slip, change name and vanish from the radar, in more or less regular cycles.
For anyone who has followed this world for a while, the Asian spin-off had become one of those stories you greet with a raised eyebrow out of sheer reflex: a bit like yet another announcement of Liechtenstein’s debut, or the rumours that every winter have some multi-award-winning pop star (we all remember the fandom’s hysteria over Rina Sawayama possibly throwing her hat in the ring) ready to rescue the United Kingdom. And yet, no: eleven countries, one single night and the first “golden microphone” officially handed out. This time it really happened.
MAKE IT OR BREAK IT
To be fair, we had known for a while that something was cooking. This time, though, it wasn’t the EBU pulling the strings directly, but Voxovation: the Los Angeles-based company that has held the licence to export the Eurovision brand outside Europe for a few years now, founded by Peter Settman and Christer Björkman. For those who don’t know him, Björkman is one of those figures without whom modern Eurovision wouldn’t be what it is: Sweden’s representative at Eurovision 1992, held “on home soil”, producer of Melodifestivalen from 2002 to 2021 – which under his leadership became the national selection model copied across half of Europe – and then the deus ex machina of several editions of Eurovision proper, from Malmö 2013 to Stockholm 2016, all the way to his role as contest producer in Malmö 2024 and Basel 2025. For better or worse, the man who has shaped the look and the rules of the game more than anyone else over the last twenty years.
The same Björkman-Settman tandem had already taken the format to the United States with the American Song Contest, broadcast in spring 2022 on NBC: 56 states and territories competing, Snoop Dogg and Kelly Clarkson hosting, AleXa winning – and then silence, with falling ratings and no renewal. An adventure that ended badly, in my view more because of the network than of the people who came up with it. NBC bit off more than it could chew, forcing the format’s “guardians” to bend to the rules of American TV in an ugly hybrid of eight episodes, with qualifiers and semi-finals leading to an 11-act final without the classic “Eurovision” liturgy we love and know by heart. The result had very little Eurovision about it and looked more like a talent show with a rather odd formula – albeit with a selection of songs that, it must be said, was very strong and in my opinion has stood the test of time well.
At the end of October, however, an investigation published by Tobbe Ek in Aftonbladet lifted the lid on the conditions in which the show was heading to Bangkok. The project unveiled with a fanfare during Vienna week had already shrunk considerably, giving way to the first humiliating back-of-the-envelope sums: a budget slashed by around one million dollars out of 4.5 (almost a quarter) with the EBU’s blessing; a large part of the international crew sent home to save on flights and accommodation and replaced by Thai technicians from S2O Productions; Settman out of the company since July, citing “personal reasons”. To complete the picture, a Voxovation that at the time of writing is practically unreachable – no website, no social media profiles, not even an address to write to (!) – and a new majority shareholder: RJ Phillips, the man behind the Zoop app, which had also positioned itself as Eurovision Asia’s main sponsor.
Zoop is worth pausing on for a moment. Phillips, previously part of the team that turned the paid-content platform OnlyFans into a global giant, launched it as a blockchain-based platform for digital celebrity trading cards, before recycling it into a “creator-friendly” social network. In May it became founding partner, with a 10-million-dollar cheque, of the much-talked-about Enhanced Games: the so-called “doping Olympics”, with none other than Peter Thiel and Donald Trump Jr. among the backers. We all know how that ended: on 24 May, in an arena thrown up in the car park of a Las Vegas casino, 42 athletes competed with doping allowed under medical supervision. World records were supposed to rain down: only one fell – obviously not recognised by any federation – in the 50 metres freestyle, set by Greece’s Kristian Gkolomeev. The whole operation, which aimed to replace the model represented by the Olympic Games by putting lavish prizes on the table for its pioneering athletes, ran into near-total rejection from the public and condemnation from critics, the media and sporting authorities. A fiasco that Enhanced co-founder Christian Angermayer nevertheless managed to claim as a “great commercial success”, naturally upping the ante for 2027 and promising 10 million dollars to whoever manages to run the 100 metres under the iconic 9.58 set 17 years ago by Usain Bolt.
Right up to the debut, in any case, the question wasn’t who would win but whether there would be a contest at all. Voxovation denied any talk of cancellation or postponement, Martin Green (EBU) assured everyone that the budget was “in line with the ambitions”, but meanwhile rumours were circulating about tickets still on sale and unspecified “frictions” between the surviving members of the international team and their Thai colleagues. All of this was made worse by a choice that, on paper, deserved applause: almost every country held a proper national final, streamed to the whole world. It’s an approach I wholeheartedly support, because national selections have always been the lifeblood of Eurovision and give the public a say in choosing their representative – and, in this case, a chance to get familiar with a new format – but it inevitably inflated the costs of a project that was already struggling.
Beyond a certain point, with all the artists chosen and the suitcases packed, pulling out was no longer an option. Bangkok became a make-or-break test: in case of disaster it would have been all too easy to shelve the whole thing and sweep it under the carpet. The EBU, after all, has recently put together quite a collection of missteps, from the Eurovision Live Tour cancelled in February to the slow erosion of the main brand’s credibility caused by the ongoing boycott by several countries in protest at Israel’s participation. Precisely for this reason, and because of everything you could read in Aftonbladet and elsewhere, expectations on the eve of the show were rock bottom.
THE SHOW
And yet, surprise of surprises: I enjoyed the night. Of course, the “experimental” nature of this first edition was obvious a mile off – there was no shortage of technical slip-ups, from microphones cutting out to camera cuts that came sometimes too early and sometimes too late, and just a few hours before the live show there were still tickets available for a One Bangkok Forum of around 6,000 seats. But the end result had a charm I really didn’t expect, one that took me straight back to the Eurovisions of the late 2000s and early 2010s, the ones I started with: editions often hosted in the East, by countries using the stage to introduce themselves to the rest of the continent, with productions that weren’t always flawless but were full of identity and personality. And, all things considered, far more enjoyable than the American Song Contest: here the format remained recognisable, with a single night, country-by-country voting and the final ritual of the 12 points, instead of being turned upside down to suit a TV network.
There would be a lot to say about the hosting of Cindy Bishop and Woody Milintachinda: lots of energy, perhaps too much, and an over-the-top register light years away from the measured elegance European presenters have accustomed us to – with Bishop’s voice, loaded with unwarranted enthusiasm, at times putting our eardrums to the test. The ideas were much better, even the ones that cost next to nothing. The flag parade with the contestants arriving on colourful tuk-tuks, the symbol of Bangkok; the postcards, which picked up the Malmö 2024 concept with the artists filmed around their own countries; and above all the video segments in which each singer acted as a guide to their own nation, or prepared small traditional gifts to exchange with their “rivals”. For a European audience that knows little or nothing about Laos, Bhutan or Mongolia, it was a little journey into an Asia far removed from the tourist brochures, and IMHO one of the most successful moments of the night.
As for the guests, the local slot went to Jeff Satur – one of the most-streamed Thai artists in the world on Spotify – who landed on stage after an online contest that sparked plenty of debate; the European one went to Dara, the reigning champion of the “real” Eurovision, who besides the inevitable Bangaranga performed her new single Bad Idea, released at the end of October. We also saw Delta Goodrem via video link, fourth in Vienna 2026 for Australia, who in the preceding weeks had accompanied the build-up with a series of covers of the competing songs on Eurovision Asia’s social channels.
THE WINNER
🇵🇭 The first Eurovision Asia trophy goes to the Philippines, thanks to 19-year-old newcomer Carmelle San Juan Collado and the song Sobra-Sobra (Too much), written by Gianina Camille Del Rosario and Mart Sam Emmanuel B. Olavides and sung in a mix of English and Tagalog.
On paper it was the entry that stuck most closely to the classic Eurovision girlbop recipe: a four-on-the-floor chorus with rap sections and Latin pop rhythms, plus the obligatory dance break in which Carmelle let loose alongside several female dancers. Its merit, though, was handling the theme of female empowerment without overdoing it, in a less maximalist and less vulgar way than we have often seen at Eurovision in recent years (cf. Serving, Miriana Conte, Malta 2025). If I really have to find a flaw, it lies in the last 30 seconds, where they tried to cram in absolutely everything: choreography, a shower of fireworks and a barrage of vocal acrobatics paying tribute to the glorious Filipino tradition of live singing (and of karaoke, practically a national sport over there). In any case, Carmelle’s “sobra-sobra” worked: first place with the juries (93 points, five sets of 12) and total domination of the public vote (118 points, an average of 10.73 for each of the sets of votes she could receive), for a total of 211.
THE REST OF THE TOP5
🇹🇭 Silver medal for the hosts. Mang (Piyatida Lekklang), a rising voice on the Thai scene, and Daou (Pittaya Saechua), a young actor with an unexpectedly good set of pipes and a familiar face from BL series – boys’ love, the genre that in recent years has turned Thailand into a small entertainment superpower across Asia – brought Aroma, a traditional ballad with a high sucrose content. The performance at times veered into melodrama, but anyone with even a passing familiarity with the genre knows that’s the norm there, and it came across as sincere. Honourable mention for Daou, who lost his headset microphone during a tricky move in which he had to free himself from his costume and carried on singing perfectly while holding it in his hand. On the eve of the show nobody would have bet a penny on them: by the end of the night they had finished second with 170 points, 62 from the juries and a whopping 108 from the public.
🇻🇳 The podium stays in the family – that of Southeast Asia, which in the end took the entire top 5. Vietnam relied on Nguyễn Khoa Tóc Tiên, a true homegrown diva, and the song Em Tiên, a title that plays on the artist’s name and on the tiên, the fairies of Vietnamese tradition. The song draws on quan họ folk singing to portray today’s Vietnamese woman, alternating Vietnamese, English and a few lines in Thai as a nod to the hosts. Chosen by the public from the five songs the singer had presented in The Sound of Vietnam, it arrived in Bangkok reworked and with one of the most ambitious (and expensive) stagings of the night: an ethereal fairy-creature dress, dancers and the classic closing dance break. After rehearsals it had firmly joined the ranks of the dark horses, and third place with 164 points (83 from the juries, 81 from the public), achieved while opening the show – a notoriously thankless slot – did it full justice.
🇲🇾 Malaysia, on the other hand, comes out battered and bruised. Nurul Aina Abdul Ghani was the pre-show favourite with Bluest Sky, a modern power ballad sung flawlessly, wrapped in a lavish white gown. The trouble is that the juries, whom on paper she should have won over unanimously, placed her only third (82 points), and the public snubbed her even more (sixth with just 70 points). In my opinion she was let down by a staging that was far too static for a song that was never really that competitive, with the first verse and first chorus spent inside a sort of “raindrop” shot from above at an unflattering angle: an idea that perhaps worked on paper, but on screen somewhat diminished the performance and the singer’s chances. Not even closing the running order was enough to turn the night around: fourth place and a disappointment that’s hard to hide.
🇱🇦 Laos’ Thinla (Thinlamphone Mahavong), on the other hand, can be happy with fifth place (139 points in total) for the lightweight, booty-shaking Bae, which became a meme from the national selection onwards precisely because of the obsessive repetition of the word “bae” and lyrics that weren’t exactly among the most mature in the competition (to put it mildly). And yet it held its own extremely well, despite an in-ear monitor failure that threw the live performance into disarray and forced the production, in the interest of fairness, to replay Friday’s dress rehearsal version at the end of the competition.
THE BIG FLOP: SOUTH KOREA
🇰🇷 If there was one real disappointment, in my view it flies the South Korean flag. Bangkok welcomed JUNHEE (Park Junhee), former leader and main vocalist of A.C.E. – a second- or third-tier name in a K-pop landscape that churns out stars non-stop – with Deep Dive, co-written by AleXa (Alexaundra Schneiderman), the American Song Contest 2022 winner who was seen again this year at Sweden’s Melodifestivalen. It was the most modern and “Western” song of the bunch, the only one entirely in English, built around an extremely complex choreography that perhaps ended up overshadowing both song and vocals – with the addition of a bit of gratuitous nudity from the performer, a hammy move that ultimately didn’t pay off.
The point, though, isn’t so much the entry as the result: seventh in the public vote with 52 points, seventh in the overall ranking too. For a country with Korea’s cultural clout, the promotional machine of K-pop and the hallyu behind it and resources the envy of everyone else, that’s a slap in the face. And it confirms a phenomenon many pointed out straight after the show: Southeast Asia – with the honourable exception of Singapore, which however wasn’t in Bangkok – has gradually grown tired of K-pop in recent years, preferring its own music scenes. The numbers speak for themselves: between 2023 and 2026, K-pop’s share of the Spotify top 50 in Thailand fell from 27% to 11% while local music rose from 65% to 78%, and in the Philippines homegrown songs went from 44% to 63%. If Korea wants to improve on this seventh place in future, it will inevitably have to reckon with this factor and bring a radically different entry – or, conversely, look for new allies among countries more in tune with its musical output.
WHAT’S REALLY AT STAKE: THE NEW VOTING SYSTEM
If there is one reason why Bangkok mattered to the EBU far more than its ratings, it lies in the voting mechanism. Because Eurovision Asia, as well as being a spin-off, was also (and perhaps above all) a testing ground for what could become the future of Eurovision.
Here’s how it worked: no phone or SMS, but voting exclusively online on the official website. To vote you had to be over 18, log in with a Google, Apple or Privy account and pass an automated anti-bot check. Each user had eight free votes to spread across at least three different songs – obviously without being able to vote for their own country; anyone who wanted could buy an additional pack of ten votes, with a cap of 16 votes for any single song. Votes from viewers outside the eleven competing countries were pooled into a single “Rest of the World” set, which was added to those of the participants in the traditional 50/50 balance between juries and public.
The link with the “real” Eurovision isn’t just my speculation. As early as August, when the system was unveiled for the first national selections, many read it as a dress rehearsal for 2027. A few weeks later, according to Aftonbladet and the BBC, the EBU reportedly wrote to broadcasters proposing a fully online public vote, with viewers required to pick their top three, and the organisation itself confirmed that it had “begun investigating” the move. The logic is clear: having already halved from 20 to 10 the maximum number of votes per payment method ahead of Vienna, the EBU is looking for a way – not too openly declared – to defuse the vote of a compact diaspora (whichever it may be) or one mobilised around a predetermined cause. In recent years we’ve seen it above all with Ukraine and Israel, for diametrically opposite reasons, but as I’ve said before: nothing, and I mean NOTHING, prevents it from being someone else’s turn tomorrow. Forcing the public to spread their preferences, and making them free, means diluting the weight of those who vote ten times for the same song and rewarding instead the songs that can appeal across the board.
As far as I’m concerned, the test was a success: I got onto the site and voted in a matter of seconds, without any hitch whatsoever. Of course, the login barrier – as Ben Robertson points out on ESC Insight – risks favouring a young, tech-savvy audience, and without the full televoting data it’s hard to understand how the votes were really distributed and what balance they produced. Then there are two unknowns that no number will settle any time soon. A field of eleven songs is not a 26-song final, and the dynamics that worked in Bangkok could change radically on a European scale; on top of that, eight votes to be split across at least three songs open the door to very different strategies – the 6-1-1 of someone with only one real favourite who “throws away” the other two votes, the 3-3-1-1 of the undecided, the tactical vote of those who carefully avoid rewarding their favourite’s most dangerous rival. How the public will really behave, and how this might affect the outcome, we’ll find out sooner or later; for now these are questions that remain unanswered.
THE SOUTHEAST ASIAN (ASEAN) BLOC
Unmistakably, the first Eurovision Asia spoke the language of Southeast Asia. Proving it with hard numbers is impossible, since Voxovation is still keeping the televoting details under wraps – but my strong impression was that the countries of the ASEAN bloc (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) backed each other, especially in the public vote, with only Cambodia left behind, partly due to a few too many vocal slips. The rules did the rest: unable to vote for their own country and obliged to spread their preferences across at least three nations, viewers naturally looked to their “musical” next-door neighbours. In all intellectual honesty, it must be said that it wasn’t just neighbourly voting: South Korea aside, it was precisely the ASEAN countries that brought the liveliest and most contemporary entries, while Bangladesh, Bhutan, Nepal and Mongolia – with interesting and even distinctive songs, but more retro or niche – were objectively playing in a different league.
CENSORSHIP AND CRITICISM IN MALAYSIA
The sour note of the night, however, didn’t come from the stage but from one of the participating broadcasters. TV3, the Media Prima channel broadcasting the event in Malaysia, saw fit to censor the live show: when the Philippine jury’s votes were announced, spokesperson Vice Ganda – drag queen and one of the best-loved faces of Manila television – was covered with the Eurovision Asia logo while announcing their top 3, which incidentally gave Malaysia the maximum points. Martin Green said he was “surprised and disappointed”, specifying that the alteration only concerned the Malaysian broadcast and announcing a letter to Voxovation asking for an explanation; the production company, for its part, promised to work with the broadcaster “to make sure this doesn’t happen again”.
My position is twofold. On the one hand, exporting Eurovision to a region with sensibilities very different from ours means accepting cultural clashes that we in Europe are no longer used to – although, come to think of it, Europe isn’t immune either: Hungary said goodbye to Eurovision in 2020 without an official reason, although according to rumours from its public broadcaster the problem was that the contest had become a little too “rainbow” for the tastes of Viktor Orbán’s government. On the other hand, those who choose to take part accept the show as the organiser packages it, and can’t cut it as they please. The crux is that here the EBU’s hands are tied: Media Prima isn’t one of its members and can’t be called to order as a European broadcaster would be. Everything goes through Voxovation, and the leverage is considerably weaker.
Green said he was astonished, but for anyone with even a passing knowledge of that part of the world the episode was anything but unpredictable. In Malaysia being gay is not in itself a crime, but “homosexual acts” are, with sentences of up to 20 years; and just last year TV3 itself had to apologise publicly because some audience members at one of its shows had turned up dressed as women. Not to mention that back in the summer executive producer Assaf Blecher had admitted he didn’t think Asia was ready for “full campy, gay, over-the-top” performances. So I doubt Green was really caught off guard. Rather, I believe the line is one of patience, and that the EBU’s aim is to give the different sensibilities time to get familiar with the spirit of the format, without showing anyone the door after an openly experimental first edition that above all needs to find continuity and hold on to its early adopters. Of course, this doesn’t rule out that Malaysia and Media Prima might decide on their own to pull out in the future.
THE FUTURE OF EUROVISION ASIA
On the ratings front, the picture is two-sided. The product seems to have potential in some markets, but in several countries (Vietnam and Thailand above all) it ended up on secondary channels, with rather modest figures relative to the population. What saved the day were above all the fans of the individual artists, some of whom are genuine stars at home. The only figure published so far is the Vietnamese one: over 5 million viewers reached on VTV3, but an average audience of around one million, in a country with a population of just over a hundred million. There is no overall figure; the EBU merely lets it be known that votes came from 183 countries and territories.
The Philippine victory, on the other hand, bodes well for the future, not least because Manila has every interest in bidding to host a second edition (which here, unlike at Eurovision, doesn’t automatically go to the winner but goes through a bidding process). Let’s call it a success, or at least a narrow escape: no disaster, no new image crisis and a night that most viewers enjoyed. There were eleven countries at the start, but according to Blecher the queue for 2027 is much longer: there is talk of 16 or 17 countries and territories interested, with Taiwan, China and Hong Kong at the front, while China, India and Japan reportedly negotiated for this year already without managing to sign in time.
For the brand to really take root – and the ambition of bringing together around the same table a vast region lacking the shared history that binds Europe is anything but trivial – two things are needed, in my view. The first: the show must become a recognised event in the countries that take part, and not just a one-off curiosity to engage the Old Continent’s eurofans “out of season”. The second, with all the challenges it brings: managing to involve the heavyweights of Asian music still absent from the contest, from China to Japan, from Singapore to Taiwan to Hong Kong, by way of India, Indonesia and Kazakhstan.
The Arab world, meanwhile, is destined to remain out of the picture: partly for the sensitivity reasons mentioned above (let’s just say that glitter, drag queens and rainbow flags wouldn’t be welcomed with unbridled enthusiasm there either), and partly – above all – because of the time zone. No drama: Voxovation has already put on display a Eurovision Arab World for the 22 countries of the Arab League. Do we believe it? Let’s just say that, after eighteen years of waiting for the Asian one, I’ve learnt not to hold my breath.
